2024-2025 Underrated players of the season

MaraDon

Wants you to learn about football
I wanted to take a moment to highlight some of the most underrated players this season—those who've flown under the radar but have been absolutely exceptional week in and week out. These are the players who don’t always grab the headlines, but when you pay close attention, you realize they’ve been integral to their team’s success.

Jurrien Timber
Timber has been nothing short of a revelation this season. His consistency is incredible, and he's been a rock at the back, every single game. It’s hard to overstate just how much of a must-have he’s become in the starting eleven. Every performance feels like a masterclass in defensive positioning, composure, and leadership.

David Raya
When Arteta took the gamble on Raya, many questioned it, but it’s paid off in ways few could have predicted. Raya’s performances have exceeded expectations—he’s emerged as one of the top three keepers in the league and possibly the best Spain has to offer in the coming years. His shot-stopping ability is elite, but it’s his calmness under pressure and skill with the ball at his feet that truly set him apart. Top five keeper in the world, hands down.

John McGinn
McGinn continues to be the beating heart of Aston Villa. The way he uses his body to shield the ball, his relentless engine, and his sharp footballing IQ are crucial to Villa’s success. This season has been another solid one for him, and it’s clear why he’s so important to the team. His work rate and leadership go unnoticed by many, but they’re a key part of Villa’s rise.

Youri Tielemans
McGinn has found his perfect partner in Tielemans. The Belgian is technically flawless, and his passing range is phenomenal—he can pick out a ball that others simply can’t. Unfussy, smart, and an excellent link-up player, Tielemans was a smart acquisition by Unai Emery. Their partnership in midfield is looking solid and potentially long-lasting.

Milad Kerkez
Why don’t we talk more about Kerkez? He’s been one of the most exciting fullbacks in the league. With both feet, pace to burn, and a sharp mind, he’s made such a big impact on his team. His ability to get forward and support attacks is second to none, but he also defends with the discipline of a veteran. And don’t forget, he's the reason why players like Semenyo can thrive—Kerkez gives them the freedom to express themselves.

Johan Huijsen
Now here's a surprise. Huijsen is a defender who plays like he's been in the game for 10 years. Tall players often have a reputation for being a bit clunky, but not Huijsen. Technically superb, comfortable on the ball, and a beast in the air, he reads the game with the maturity of a seasoned pro, even though he’s still a kid. A truly exciting talent who’s impressed the league this season.

Honorable Mention: Justin Kluivert
What a season he’s having. Kluivert’s raw ability, especially in attack, has been a standout feature. His pace, technique, and knack for finding the back of the net make him a constant threat. He’s certainly one to watch as he continues to grow.

Mikkel Damsgaard
Damsgaard is one of the main reasons Brentford is so dangerous on the break. His pace, intelligence, and technical ability are combined with a phenomenal work ethic. He knows exactly when to carry the ball and when to release it with that killer pass. A player who doesn’t get nearly enough credit, but is crucial to Brentford's success this season.

Carlos Baleba
At just 21 years old, Baleba is a gem. Sure, he has moments where he makes mistakes—he’s still learning—but his composure on the ball is remarkable for someone so young. His vision, his reading of the game, and his technical ability are all top-tier. Brighton is a tough team to break into, but he’s shown he’s more than capable of handling the pressure. He’s a delight to watch, and you can tell he’s going to keep getting better.

Nico Jackson
When Nkunku arrived at Chelsea, many expected him to be the main man up front. But Jackson’s hard work and intelligence have made him a key player for the Blues this season. He’s much more than just a striker who scores goals—he’s involved in build-up play, defensively solid, and a real team player. I’m pleasantly surprised by his impact, and he’s proven to be a striker capable of leading the line for any top club.

Daniel Muñoz
Could Daniel Muñoz be the fullback of the season? His energy, pace, and strength are incredible, and he's just as effective going forward as he is defensively. A true modern fullback with a perfect blend of technical skill and power. His work rate is unmatched, and he’s always in the right place at the right time.

Jean-Philippe Mateta
Mateta is the type of striker that you know will create something out of nothing. His physical presence, technical skill, and ability in the air make him a nightmare for defenders. He may not have the speed or flair of the new-age forwards, but he’s a throwback to the kind of player who can change a game with a simple flick or header. A player who commands attention, even when he isn’t scoring.

Abdoulaye Doucouré
Doucouré is the unsung hero of Everton’s midfield. While players like Ndiaye and Beto get the headlines, Doucouré’s tireless work, key interceptions, and incredible positioning often go unnoticed. He’s one of those players who does the dirty work, and when he’s missing, you realize just how much he contributes. Underrated and incredibly valuable.

Calvin Bassey
Bassey has taken his game to new heights this season. What we saw last season was only a glimpse, but now he’s a key figure in a side that’s been one of the most exciting to watch. His strength, speed, and technical ability make him an all-around force. Whether defending or moving the ball forward, he’s been instrumental in his team’s performances.

Raúl Jiménez
I know what you're thinking—why is Jiménez on this list? But hear me out: when you’re a defender, there are certain players you just don’t want to face. Jiménez, while not as prolific as some others, has that raw, physical presence that makes him a nightmare. He’s a tough challenge for any center-back, and he has that Drogba-esque aura. He’s got a certain menace in his game that makes him one of the hardest strikers to play against.

Gravenberch & Mac Allister
While all the attention goes to Szoboszlai, this pairing has quietly been the heart of Liverpool’s midfield. Their consistency, technical quality, and tactical awareness make them the most underrated midfield duo in the league. They’re calm under pressure and have been absolutely crucial in Liverpool’s success this season. In terms of pure midfield balance, they’re the best in the league right now.

Bruno Fernandes
Now, don’t shoot me, but I’m putting Bruno here. United fans might not appreciate him, but let's be real—Bruno is one of the top five players in the league. His consistency, creativity, and leadership have been central to United’s attack for years now. When he’s on his game, he’s one of the best attacking midfielders in Europe. An elite footballer, no doubt.

Anthony Hall
Another young talent who’s been impressive is Hall. At just 20, he plays like someone far older than his years. He’s technically gifted, fearless in duels, and always willing to take on defenders. His attitude is spot-on, and he’s a joy to watch. You can see him becoming a real force in the coming seasons.

Morgan Gibbs-White
How is Gibbs-White not a regular in the England squad? His influence on Nottingham Forest this season has been massive—he’s the heartbeat of the team. Technically brilliant, intelligent, with a fantastic work rate and vision. He’s the type of player who can turn a game in an instant and make those around him better. A true elite talent who deserves far more recognition.

Tomas Souček
Souček is the kind of player who fits perfectly into Moyes’ system—a big, imposing midfielder with excellent technical ability. He’s been moved into a more advanced role this season, and his presence in the box is proving to be an asset. He’s the type of player that every mid-table team would love to have in their squad, and his ability to dominate aerial duels gives him an edge.

What are your picks?
 

Dokaka

Gunner come out of the closet any day now…
No offense mate but 80% of those picks are quite known/rated by most fans, no?

But to add my own, it has to be Aaron Wan-Bissaka. Gone from a player labeled as a purely defensive FB to one of our best attacking threats, taking on players like a winger and generally being very involved in attack. Probably our player of the season and he's surprised me to say the least. I still see a lot of people go "wtf???" when they face us and he does something great going forward.

Another shout is Maxence Lacroix at Palace, think he's been far better than Guehi this season and has stepped into the pretty big shoes Andersen left when he joined Fulham.
 
Last edited:

MaraDon

Wants you to learn about football
No offense mate but 80% of those picks are quite known/rated by most fans, no?

But to add my own, it has to be Aaron Wan-Bissaka. Gone from a player labeled as a purely defensive FB to one of our best attacking threats, taking on players like a winger and generally being very involved in attack. Probably our player of the season and he's surprised me to say the least. I still see a lot of people go "wtf???" when they face us and he does something great going forward.

Another shout is Maxence Lacroix at Palace, think he's been far better than Guehi this season and has stepped into the pretty big shoes Andersen left when he joined Fulham.
I really don't see many fans talking about these players as much as we should. Agreed with AWB, not convinced with Lacroix just yet, but he looks very, very good.

There are some teams I haven't picked anyone just because I don't watch them enough, Like Southampton, Ipswich, and Leicester.
 

jones

Captain Serious
No offense mate but 80% of those picks are quite known/rated by most fans, no?

But to add my own, it has to be Aaron Wan-Bissaka. Gone from a player labeled as a purely defensive FB to one of our best attacking threats, taking on players like a winger and generally being very involved in attack. Probably our player of the season and he's surprised me to say the least. I still see a lot of people go "wtf???" when they face us and he does something great going forward.

Another shout is Maxence Lacroix at Palace, think he's been far better than Guehi this season and has stepped into the pretty big shoes Andersen left when he joined Fulham.
Lacroix is a prick but he was a monster at Wolfsburg, very reminiscent of a young Saliba. Lost his way a bit but seems to have found his form again, if we sold the latter to Madrid he'd be the best like for like replacement.
 

Dokaka

Gunner come out of the closet any day now…
Lacroix is a prick but he was a monster at Wolfsburg, very reminiscent of a young Saliba. Lost his way a bit but seems to have found his form again, if we sold the latter to Madrid he'd be the best like for like replacement.

Yeah I thought he looked unreal when he broke into the team at Wolfsburg but he just didn't kick on, was downright poor the last couple of seasons IMO. The move to Palace seems to have reinvigorated him.
 

teamsoutheast

🤔🤔🤔 I want to believe 🤔🤔🤔

Country: USA

Player:Ødegaard
Another shout is Maxence Lacroix at Palace, think he's been far better than Guehi this season and has stepped into the pretty big shoes Andersen left when he joined Fulham.
Definitely agree with you on Lacroix..
 

MikelHadADream

...and then He woke up sweating !!!
Good thread. Hard to be underrated these days, especially at a middle of the road club.

Because of the nerds your Baleba’s and Kerkez’s, your traditional “underrated” players, are raved about, especially online.
 

Buhry

Established Member

Country: Norway
Someone like Bruno is very much rated. And he has been carrying that awful team the last 2 months.

I'd say Gabriel is still somewhat underrated outside of Arsenal. Or maybe not but Saliba seems to be the bigger name anyway, maybe because he is french and linked to Real but Gabriel is immense.

Mbuemo is having an immense season, so I'd say he is a bit slept on. Maybe because he looks like he is 35 and about to retire but he is still quite young and could still have his best years ahead of him.
 

Dennis_Bergkamp_10

Established Member

Country: Netherlands

Player:Ødegaard
De Ligt at Man Utd I think, he's been pretty good despite everyone going on about their **** defence.
 

Stevo the Villan

Established Member
John McGinn
McGinn continues to be the beating heart of Aston Villa. The way he uses his body to shield the ball, his relentless engine, and his sharp footballing IQ are crucial to Villa’s success. This season has been another solid one for him, and it’s clear why he’s so important to the team. His work rate and leadership go unnoticed by many, but they’re a key part of Villa’s rise.

Youri Tielemans
McGinn has found his perfect partner in Tielemans. The Belgian is technically flawless, and his passing range is phenomenal—he can pick out a ball that others simply can’t. Unfussy, smart, and an excellent link-up player, Tielemans was a smart acquisition by Unai Emery. Their partnership in midfield is looking solid and potentially long-lasting.
The fact you've mentioned these two, but haven't mentioned our best and most underrated player just proves how underrated he actually is

Boubacar Kamara
 

Rex Stone

I am a man and I’m relentless

Country: Wales

Player:Nwaneri
Inigo Martinez.

Doesn’t have the profile of Araujo or the hype of Curbasi but I think he’s a really underrated defender over the course of his career who’s been excellent this year.

He’s been on the periphery of the National Team most of his career but I’d have him as a similar ability to Pique honestly.
 

Arsenal Quotes

Everyone thinks they have the prettiest wife at home

Arsène Wenger

Latest posts

Top Bottom