Pat's missing Gerbil
Active Member
i can only speak for what the FA do. All clubs in england across all four divisions have to a screening medical examination, electrocardiograph and cardiac ultrasound examination for a player to have professional status. All players signing for big clubs get a very thorough medical examination and investigation prior to signing.unknown-gunner said:i think FIFA should put the onus on the clubs, ensuring regular rigorous medical tests are performed, especially for top flight clubs. lower clubs dont have as much money to afford this, so maybe more lax rules for them.
we cant let any more people die on the pitch. its not good for the playes and its not good from the game. hopefully FIFA will learn from this latest tragedy.
I am afraid the event of sudden cardiac death would not be predictable on such tests. Its cause is due to sudden electrical chaos within the heart and the heart's regular beating stops. This can occur in athlete's heart because of their training changing the muscular structure of the heart. It can occur in an athelete for the same reason as most of us ie a blood clot forming in one of the blood vessels to the heart and disrupting the blood supply to the heart muscle which in turn leads to electrical chaos. The trick to surviving such events is to have people able to CPR and not stop it because it may upset the croud. It is also fundemental to have early defibrillation to shock the heart out of the electrical chaos. I believe that if both of these atheletes had early recognition of the event, early continuous CPR, and early defibrillation, that there would have been a good chance that they would have survived intact. What is criminal is that they did not get it.
All we can do to predict whether an athelete is fit for his sport is look at the heart to see if the muscular structure is not too disordered (hypertrophic cardiomyopathy) and that they have no valvular heart disease (eg Kanu had aortic valve stenosis and required aortic valve replacement). I am afraid that there are seldom definite ways of predicting where lightening will strike. You have to deal with the consequences. It is the ineptness of the way in which this has been done that concerns me.