Reyes was improving, he was a big player for us, the guy joined the best club in the world at the time for big money. Massive success for Wenger.
Podolski done his job. Getting dropped later doesn’t mean you’re a flop, our team developed and others were more suited than him later on.
I judge signings by whether they outperform or underperform their potential. Reyes didn’t reach his potential at Arsenal. A commonly accepted fact.