Squad Analysis 2017/18

Discussion in 'Arsenal Talk' started by Aevius, Jun 1, 2016.

  1. Aevius

    Aevius Pro-Rambo Moderator

    .
     
  2. truth_hurts

    truth_hurts Well-Known Member

    Started from the bottom of the page (Arsenal talk) posted in the squad analysis 2015/16 topic, now i'm here! Repost:

    Debuchy looks likely to leave as do Ospina and Gibbs. We need 2 defenders - I love the Rodriguez rumour and maybe an older CB who can play RB as well (not Chambers! loan him).

    Our CM area is stacked with quality and balance now so nothing more needed there.

    Our attack lacks something. It's not creativity, to be fair all 3 of Theo Giroud and Sanchez are good for 15 league goals when fit but I feel we need a star in attack.

    Chelsea - Hazard, Costa
    City - KDB, Aguero
    Barca - MSN
    Real - HIM and Bale
    Bayern - Lewa, Muller, Robben and Ribery
    PSG - ADM, Cavani and Zlatan replacement
    Us - Just Sanchez
    Dortmud - Reus and PEA

    We meed another match winner upfront as we're too reliant on Alexis.
     
  3. Iddi

    Iddi Well-Known Member

    I am nervous for next season with Pep, Mourinho, Klopp, Poch, and Conte all fighting it out for those Top 4 place.

    I still think we are very unbalanced in midfield, the final 3rd is a joke as we only have Sanchez whom you can somewhat trust to get you a goal.

    My biggest fear is always been us out of possession, we are a complete joke and embarrassment, why can't we press the opposition? We lack intensity when we are out of possession, we are the easiest team to play againt because our player seem clueless and ain't got a scooby doo what to do when it comes to winning the ball back. This makes me nervous because we always look vulnerable when attacked.

    I hope wenger can improve this glaring deficiency in our team and make sure every single player is prepared to graft, if not then i can sense the old 6-0, 6-3, 5-1, 3-0 spankings next season.
     
    Gooner Zig likes this.
  4. Jazz

    Jazz Well-Known Member

    I’d be interested to know what people would consider the bare necessities for this transfer window. In other words, what’s the minimum we’d need to bring in for you to consider us realistic title challengers next season?

    For me even if we upgraded every position except striker I still wouldn’t consider us realistic challengers. Striker is one of the most important roles in the team and it is also the weakest position we have. At the minimum I would take an upgrade on Giroud. If that’s all we did this window I’d be pretty content. I know it’s early but all the serious links being for other positions is worrying me. I don’t really care either way if we do or do not get Riccardo Rodriguez, I do however care very much if we do or do not get a better starting striker.

    I really have 0 ****s to give if Wenger doesn’t think there are enough top top quality strikers out there right now. It’s completely and utterly his fault that we didn’t get them when they were available and needed a striker for god knows how many windows. I don’t care if you have to pay inflated prices now for the likes of PEA or Lukakku. That’s just the position you’ve put yourself in if you don’t think the other strikers out there are good enough. It’s the one think we definitely need to take the next step so we have to do whatever it takes now IMO.
     
    Gooner Zig likes this.
  5. 4R5Emaniac

    4R5Emaniac Always fresh from Bangladesh

    First of all, last season was a unique occurrence and its unlikely that it'd be repeated while there have been many changes already at other clubs. Big managerial changes and unlimited resources compared to other leagues while there is a high probability of lots of player movement. So personally I'll not get sucked in to expectations too early- as should Wenger and he absolutely has to manage expectations instead of inviting unnecessary pressure by talking out of his ass.

    As for the squad, I feel its crucial we strengthen at CB and striker after having signed Xhaka already. I'd be content with that given our history regarding transfers unless a prominent member moves on and needs replacing. If there are more additions to the first team, great. Apart from that I'd like for us to give chances to some of our kids or players out on loan-cut losses if we aren't sure.

    But even if do the unthinkable and strengthen to the maximum, I'll be cautious given our performance last season.
     
  6. truth_hurts

    truth_hurts Well-Known Member

    We need to play with more energy. Mertesacker is to slow for our system, maybe Monreal (although I rate him highly) and Giroud definitely is. We struggle to press and as said above off the ball is where we get caught out.

    It's no coincidence that we've looked better with Theo or Danny upfront, not because they are better than Giroud but because they suit the intensity of the league better. No coincidence we look lost without Coquellin either.

    Arteta has gone, Mert should be replaced by Gabriel or new cb, a bit of pace and movement up front and I think we'll be dynamic enough.

    I'd be content with Xhaka and an elite forward to be honest. Our back up is good enough, more than good enough - we desperately needed a bit more bite in Cm and still need a match winner upfront other than Sanchez.
     
  7. Jack the lad

    Jack the lad Well-Known Member

    We have to get one world class attacking player and a world class cb at the bare minimum.
     
    Kellie Price likes this.
  8. truth_hurts

    truth_hurts Well-Known Member

    There isn't a world class CB available though.
     
  9. BobP

    BobP Favre Fan

    Few question marks in our squad.

    Bellerin is obviously fine, but what about his backup? Debuchy has proven to be useless and is not exactly young, and Jenkinson was exposed at West Ham.

    Monreal has had a great season, but he's not getting any younger. Gibbs is mediocre and is now almost 27.

    Mertesackers contract comes to an end at the end of the coming season, Koscielny is also getting on. There's been talk of Chambers going out on loan.

    We also lack a proper goalscorer.

    In my eyes, thats 4 more players we'll need

    CB
    RB
    LB
    ST
     
  10. cloista

    cloista Active Member

    With regular game time I think Chambers could develop into a very good centre back and a decent right back, he showed a lot of potential in his first season here. If he's not going to play regularly for us he needs a loan this season though. A replacement for Merts is needed though, Gabriel is 3rd choice at best and Merts really should be 4th choice now. Stones would be an expensive but ideal signing, with Stones and Chambers that's a potential club and country pairing if they can develop well. Jenks is similar enough to Bellerin in style to be cover. If Gibbo goes, I'd like to see Cresswell from West Ham, been solid for a good few seasons now.

    The biggest issue is ofcourse up front. While I have faith in Welbeck to be a good frontman for us eventually, his injury has set him back a lot. I'd want someone with a very good goal record, I'd actually like to see if we could pick up someone like Griezmann, I think he could do a passable impression of Henry the way his game is developing. Theo can stay as cover until Welbeck regains fitness. Giroud would be fine as a plan B, it's having him as Plan A-F that's the problem.

    If we can move on the likes of Ox, Campbell and Gnabry, I'd like to see a cheeky bid for Nathan Redmond. He stood out in a desperately poor Norwich side even when being used sparingly, and I think he could be a great player given the chance to learn from the likes of Alexis.
     
    Last edited: Jun 3, 2016
  11. Trilly

    Trilly Runs East London

    Looking like Wenger is attempting to build a serious counter attacking side. I think signing Rodriguez will confirm it.
     
    4R5Emaniac likes this.
  12. carlitobrigante

    carlitobrigante Active Member

    If the Vardy and Rodriguez deals go through, and we get a CB, then i think we will have the best squad in the league no matter what the other teams do.

    Just think, we have last seasons team, with Arteta and Flamini, and possibly Gibbs removed. Then add to that we have Elneny, a fit Wilshere (not Wilshire ffs), an improved Iwobi, Campbell, and maybe a couple more youth prospects making the break through.

    Then add Vardy, Xhaka, and Rodriguez.

    Then imagine one of Kante, Mkhitaryan or Mahrez as a cherry on top. Unlikely i know but we can but dream! :)

    It does seem like Wenger is going all out to really compete for the season or two he has left. I'm optimistic, and looking forward to seeing how Wenger wraps up his time here.
     
  13. Aevius

    Aevius Pro-Rambo Moderator

    I really hope we keep this partnership at the club, it's as important as the new signings. They burst the ball forward so well.

     
    Rygura, Tir Na Nog and RandyMarsh like this.
  14. RandyMarsh

    RandyMarsh Well-Known Member

    Just glorious. I will be devastated if these two don't sign new contracts.
     
  15. Coolin

    Coolin Doesn't appreciate the mighty Nacho

    No one mentions it, but I think we need another winger around the same level as Sanchez. Our current wide options are horrible, a bunch of players that can do a job, but no real quality there.

    I'd even put it before a centre back. Özil, Sanchez, Vardy and a bonafide winger ... let's get back to wrecking teams 3-0 before half-time.
     
    Rygura and Dutch D like this.
  16. Linson

    Linson Well-Known Member

    Linson Low-down -

    Italics mean the player should probably be moved on, either in the form of a loan or a transfer.

    Goalkeepers

    Cech (33)
    Ospina (13)
    Szczesny (1)
    Martinez (-)

    I think we probably have the best goalkeepers in the league with these 3, sadly that probably means one of the big three will probably want to leave, if not 2. Cech is clearly Wengers favourite, Ospina has done very little wrong in his defence and I think Szczesny genuinely loves Arsenal... Difficult choices!

    RB
    Bellerin (24)
    Debuchy (2)
    Jenkinson (-)

    Jenkinson has clearly made massive strides this year and realising some of his potential, whether he is Arsenal quality is yet to be seen. Bellerin clearly deserves his place and I still think Debuchy is useful to have around due to his versatility. I think he'd make a good CB as he ages.

    LB
    Monreal (18)
    Gibbs (3)

    Monreal has been huge this season and Gibbs is an adequate replacement if he gets injured.

    CB
    Koscielny (6)
    Mertesacker (4)
    Gabriel (5)
    Chambers (21)

    I think there are some real questions over our current CB's. Mertesackers age, Gabriels competence and Chambers potential. I personally think Gabriel is not good enough and needs to be moved on, though I know a lot of people would disagree with that. Chambers needs game time as he was very good in his first season here. A lot of people on here dislike Mertesacker but the fact for me is that he is a perfect example of synergy, everyone tends to play when he is around.

    Conclusion
    Out - Gabriel transfer, ?Chambers loan
    In - At least one CB

    Defensive Midfielders

    Xhaka (29)
    Coquelin (34)
    Elneny (35)

    Enough

    Box-to-Box Midfielders
    Ramsey (8)
    Wilshere (10)
    Cazorla (19)

    Enough

    Attacking Midfielders
    Özil (11)

    Although he is the only true AM, there are others that can fill in, namely Cazorla but I also think Ramsey, Wilshere and the Ox would do a good job.

    RW
    Walcott (14)
    Oxlade-Chamberlain (15)
    Gnabry (27)
    Iwobi (17)

    Gnabry hasn't improved sufficiently and although Walcott almost guarantees goals I'm just fed up with his complete inconsistency. He is not Arsenal quality and never has been. He has been riding on the back of his potential and pace with flashes of brilliance but has never built on that foundation. He is in the prime of his footballing life now and still can't control a ball or convincingly kick one.

    Conclusion
    Out - Walcott, Gnabry
    In - x1

    LW
    Alexis (7)
    Campbell (28)

    Probably enough

    ST

    Giroud (12)
    Welbeck (23)
    Sanogo (-)

    Sanogo just hasn't got enough to compete with the current crop of strikers, which is hardly a stellar cast. He won't be able to compete with any incoming strikers.

    Conclusion
    Need at least one more stiker

    Transfers

    In

    Xhaka
    ST
    CB
    RW

    Out

    Arteta
    Rosicky
    Flamini
    Martinez
    Gabriel
    Chambers (loan)
    Gnabry
    Walcott
    Sanogo
     
    Aevius and Rygura like this.
  17. Dutch D

    Dutch D Active Member

    I've been saying the same in several topics. I think it's absolutely crazy that for a few years now we have very poor wide options and always have to improvise with midfielders or Walcott. I'd always prioritize it over a CB this year.
     
    Mark Tobias likes this.
  18. gunner4lyfe

    gunner4lyfe Well-Known Member

  19. Kanonier

    Kanonier Well-Known Member

    What do you guys think of Marc Bartra from Barcelona B? He's supposedly the "next Gerard Pique" and is available for only €8 Million. I'm surprised we are not all over him.
     
  20. Lancelot

    Lancelot Well-Known Member Trusted

    He went for Dortmund just a couple of days ago, mate.

     

Share This Page