Thought it'd be interesting to hear people's opinion on this. The first player who comes to mind is Koscielny. He's easily one of the best CBs in the EPL, yet he's never mentioned as one by the media or other fans. Sagna is underrated as well. He's been performing great for several years now and been one of the first names on your team sheet. I think both Milner and Barry are good players too. Both are solid, hard working midfielders who do their job well but have basically no flair, which I think is what hurts them.