Top 10 GK’s in PL History

[Mitch]

View attachment 44083

Carra’s list causing some controversy. Can’t believe Nigel Martyn didn’t make it, even Lloris would have a better case than Reina imo.

Agreed!

Martyn and Flowers are criminally underrated.

Martyn - 3 x Time PFA TOTY & 2 x PL most clean sheets in a season. The best English GK after Seaman in my lifetime. One of best GK performances I've seen is him against us. Wright was shaking his head in disbelief with some of the saves he was making against him.

Flowers - 2 x Time PFA TOTY and PL winner. I rate Flowers higher than Hart and Pickford (both of whom are underrated too in my opinion).


My top 10
1. Schmichael
2. VDS
3. Cech
4. Seamen
5. Courtois
6. Martyn
7. DDG
8. Allison
9. Flowers
10. Lehmann

It's very close between Courtois, Martyn, DDG and Allison and interchangeable in my opinion.

Southall's prime by reputation was in the mid to late 80s before the PL. I remember him still being a very good keeper in PL from what I saw at the end of his Everton career.

Reina? Decent keeper but there's about half dozen keepers not mentioned I'd choose ahead of him.

I agree with @2Smokeyy comments relating to Ederson.

 

[Sapient Hawk]

Neville Southall was what jumped out at me

Hold your venemous tongue!! Neville Southall is a Team Hawk LEGEND & I will hear no slander!!

As for Mad Jens, I'm stunned that bald dolt, Reina, got in before he did. I mean he actually contributed to us being invincible.

Reina got his arse handed to him by Arshavin time & time again.