Winston Reid

Discussion in 'Transfer Rumours' started by invisibleman18, Jun 25, 2010.

  1. Toast

    Toast Well-Known Member

    He's nowhere near Arsenal quality though. He can make the step up to the PL, but not to a top team.
  2. GDeep™

    GDeep™ Wrong, But Rarely

    Van Dijk would be a good prospect signing if your team wasn't currently a total joke in their defensive make up.

    Not the guy when you need immediate quality.
  3. Rex Banter

    Rex Banter Knows a guy who knows an ITK at Bristol Trusted


    If you mean it's briefly exciting but ultimately leaves you empty inside then 100% agree.

    Guy is completely clueless, but hey if you throw enough s**t, some of it sticks.
  4. Iceman10

    Iceman10 Well-Known Member

    West Ham have signed a Canadian international, Doneil Henry.
    <a class="postlink" href="" onclick=";return false;"></a>

    Doesn't come across as an immediate replacement but with Tomkins, Collins, this new signing, and utility backups Kouyate and Song that may be enough for West Ham to feel they can let Reid go for a fee instead of for free at the end of the season.
  5. SiMamu

    SiMamu Part time Leeds fan

    Opportunistic cut-price deal now?
    More links:
    <a class="postlink" href="" onclick=";return false;"> ... are_btn_tw</a>
    <a class="postlink" href="" onclick=";return false;"> ... st-4920505</a>
    <a class="postlink" href="" onclick=";return false;"> ... um=twitter</a>
  6. a_fourteen

    a_fourteen Well-Known Member

    Will not happen. Reid will want assurances of starting and we will not give him that. We have an established starting pair in Mert and Kos and are grooming a young player in Chambers. We are looking for a fourth choice utility man that can play a number of positions in a pinch. Perrin rumors have more merit.
  7. GDeep™

    GDeep™ Wrong, But Rarely

    He'll join Sp**s or Liverpool. Wenger has 2 starters and and Chambers for the future.

    What I'm reading into the situation (us looking at Perrin) - Chambers is lined up to break the Kos and Per partnership.
  8. GDeep™

    GDeep™ Wrong, But Rarely

    Obviously as fans we want what other top clubs do - need a player in a certain position? Sign the best you can out there.

    Wenger again, has long term, and player development in mind, a tight budget too maybe.
  9. Toast

    Toast Well-Known Member

    I'm not keen on him as Per's replacement. He seems like a safer gamble than Perrin would be and I'd certainly prefer him over Perrin, but he'd be a gamble nonetheless. Dok's comment about Kos and Reid's playing styles not being complementary is a bit of a red flag. So I don't think he's the Per replacement we're looking for. That said, I would not be against getting this guy on a free in the summer (or for a small fee in January) provided we ship Per out in the summer and replace him with a top quality CB to partner Kos.

    Starting: Top CB - Kos
    Sub: Chambers - Reid

    Looks pretty good.

    Question for Dok: how is Reid on the ball and what would you say his biggest weakness is?
  10. Dokaka

    Dokaka AM's resident Hammer

    Average on the ball, no worse than your current CBs. It's difficult to pinpoint a specific weakness as he's a very good all-round CB.
  11. GDeep™

    GDeep™ Wrong, But Rarely

    Keown a few weeks ago had Reid in his top 5 current best PL CBs, alongside Terry, Cahill, Kos and Kompany, I think.

    Latest rumour now is that Reid has an agreement in place with a club for next summer.
  12. Iceman10

    Iceman10 Well-Known Member

    BFS has highlighted that for PL prize money each position is worth £1.8m (from his recollection, number may be a little off).

    BFS and West Ham appear to be talking about Reid quite a lot which suggests they are putting him in the shop window but taking into account prize money differences of £1.8m per PL position a fee of 4m as in some rumours looks unrealistic, would be something closer to 7-8m. A buying club then has to weigh up if that is worth it as opposed to getting the player for free at the end of the season but for me the economics still makes sense considering the cost of not qualifying for the CL which is quite possible if Kos continues to struggle to gain full health and we continue with the lack of depth at the back we've had so far this season.

    West Ham have already brought in a Canadian international (Doneil Henry). There are also some rumours about them tracking Nicolas N'Kolou in addition (suggested transfer fee approx. 6m).
  13. pikey2000

    pikey2000 Well-Known Member

    This is where we should be more ruthless as a club - 8mil is chump change for a starting CB with PL experience.

    Get him in, use him for the remainder of this season and the next and then sale him if he doesn't cut the mustard.

    Not every decision needs to have the long long term considered!!!
  14. Toast

    Toast Well-Known Member

    Is it true that only foreign clubs can sign him on a pre-contract, as BFS is claiming?
    <a class="postlink" href="" onclick=";return false;"></a>
  15. ArsenesNO1Fan

    ArsenesNO1Fan Well-Known Member

    Whether it's legal or PL teams will tap him up. Look at RVP meeting with the sheikhs while under contract.
  16. GDeep™

    GDeep™ Wrong, But Rarely

    Someone representing Liverpool, Sp**s, Everton, Utd, Arsenal, City etc would have been in touch with someone representing Reid, with an offer. Reid then gives it the OK and turns down any West Ham offer or any potential agreement with a European club.

    Every big team in the Premier League will be after a CB in the summer, work it out.
  17. Dokaka

    Dokaka AM's resident Hammer

    Yeah I've basically accepted that Reid is leaving. Too many big fish looking for a new quality CB. He'd be mental to turn down Liverpool, Arsenal, Man Utd, maybe even City and Chelsea. Life of a mid-table club.
  18. GDeep™

    GDeep™ Wrong, But Rarely

    <a class="postlink" href="" onclick=";return false;"> ... er-4929594</a>

  19. blaze_of_glory

    blaze_of_glory Moderator Moderator

    Cross kiss of death. Dead in the water I'm afraid.
  20. GDeep™

    GDeep™ Wrong, But Rarely

    Cross is normally on point, I keep a track of these things.

Share This Page

Watch Arsenal Live Streams With

Do Not Sell My Personal Information