Stack or Taylor???

[Marky249]

Who do u think should be a reserve keeper when taylor gets back to full fitness, personally im not to sure i think they are both good young keepers.

 

[gypped]

Taylor is good, to be sure, but Stack has one serious advantage that tips the scales overwhelmingly in his favour: he's Irish! :mrgreen: :angel

 

[Fuzzo]

^^ EXACTLY ^^

 

[beaney]

STACKY!

hes played brilliantly this term in the carling cup!

 

[Marky249]

stackys good but we cant forget how good taylors been 4 us, does any 1 no anything about alex manninger?

 

[Gooner83]

Taylor is more experienced.

 

[KoLo28]

stack all the way, even though we lost last night he made 2 saves to deny mozzerella, that great save plus when he was one on one his presence caused him to put his shot wide.

 

[Senght]

stackys good but we cant forget how good taylors been 4 us, does any 1 no anything about alex manninger?

Alex has been sold right?

Personally I think both keepers have been great for us but we need to give Taylor some reserve starts when he comes back from injury

 

[unknown-gunner]

they are both great, but i can honestly say that i dont feel as confident with them between the sticks as i am with jens. they need more experience, although stacky was almost flawless against middlesborough.

 

[Marky249]

any 1 no whats happend to manninger??

 

[Sol man]

Stack will be gunners no.1 in 2 yrs time. The competition will be immense between him and taylor though.

 

[beaney]

any 1 no whats happend to manninger??

SOLD last season.

 

[beaney]

oh and incase you were wondering, i think he want to Espanyol but is now at Torino.

 

[Pepe LeFrits]

Taylor was outstanding last season.

 

[n_henry]

I've seen next to nothing of Stack, so I gotta say Taylor. He was great when I saw him last season.

 

[lewdikris]

They're both pretty good. I have a feeling Taylor may jump ship to get first team action - Stacky's a year or two younger so won't be as fussed about not playing every week.

I prefer Stacky - he's got a bit more character. Apparently that view is shared inside the club. Both are very talented however.

 

[bobbypires]

They're both great. But I think Taylor will be the first choice.

 

[Anonymous]

Stack is rated higher in the club than Taylor.

Taylor is the more experienced having played Juve and the Mancs, whereas Stack hasnt played anyone of note yet.

But i would still choose Stack over Taylor. I have never rated the guy - he just looks far too thin.

 

[Chips&CurrySauce]

I have to admit i prefer Stack. He seems more determined and driven than Taylor. I don't think Taylor is decisive enough. I remember when we played Liverpool, when Riise ran onto a long ball and Taylor just remained rooted to the spot when he easliy could have ran out of his area and booted the ball away.

 

[jackycreegs]

taylor's the better 'keeper imo