Not trying to be funny here, honest question:
When was the last time we bought a player that the majority of the fans (at least the ones on here) thought “made so much sense to bring in”.
Doesn't happen often. The majority of the Starting 11, let alone the squad, consists of players who (at the time of their transfers) probably wouldn't have been consensus signings on here.
If there's doubt around the player on AM, chances are the signing will work out.