Player Ratings - PL: Manchester City vs Arsenal | 22/11/08

[Clrnc]

Almunia 4
Hoyte 5
Djourou 6
Silvest 4
Clichy 6
Diaby 3
Denilson 1
Song 5
Nasri 5
Bendtner 2
RVP 5

Subs
Vela 5
Ramsey 6

 

[kel varnsen]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Almunia 3
Hoyte 3
Djourou 4
Silvest 3
Clichy 3
Diaby 2
Denilson 1
Song 3
Nasri 4
Bendtner 2
RVP 4

Vela 4
Ramsey 6

 

[nazo]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Almunia 5
Hoyte 5
Djourou 5
Silvest 5
Clichy 5
Diaby 3
Denilson -5
Song 5
Nasri 5
Bendtner 5
RVP 5

Subs
Vela 6
Ramsey 6

 

[SimplyFabregas]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Almunia - 1

Hoyte - 3
Silvestre - 3
Djourou - 4
Clichy - 2

Song - N/A
Denilson - N/A
Diaby - N/A
Nasri - 2

Van Persie - 2
Bendtner - 1


Ramsey - 5
Vela - 4


Wenger - 0 - What was that midfield?, why didnt you use your 3 subs?, Why won't you play Wilshere?, Why won't you start Ramsey or Vela?, Why are you turning Denilson into the new Eboue?, Why, Why, Why

 

[1970*Gooner]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Almunia 2
Hoyte 2
Djourou 4
Silvest 3
Clichy 4
Diaby 2
Denilson -1
Song 3
Nasri 4
Bendtner 1
RVP 4

Vela 4
Ramsey 6

 

[Alfonso]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Gallas-3

Would have given him a 2 if it wasnt for the fact he got a late consolation goal. To be fair it was the first time he played online.

 

[giuliob]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Almunia 4
Hoyte 5 Can't fault the effort for his first PL game...
Djourou 5 Did okay...
Silvestre 5
Clichy 4 He is losing self confidence; not a good game at all...
Diaby 3 Abi "Anonymous" Diaby
Denilson -4 Just don't get how he manages to stay on the 1st team
Song 4 Nothing special
Nasri 5.5 First half he tried, and ran out of steam...
Bendtner 4.5 He epitomizes a young kid playing a man's game...
RVP 5 Another one who tried real hard; showed some spunk....

Subs
Vela 5.5 We really need to see him play more
Ramsey 5.5 Ditto

 

[tactica442]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Almunia - 5
Djourou - 4
Silverstre- 5
Clichy - 5
Gavin - 4
Denilson - 0.5 - Very very poor game from him. Did he get booked?
Song - 3
Diaby -4
Nasri - 5
Bendtner - 3
van Persie - 5

Ramsey - 6
Vela - n/a

 

[SimplyFabregas]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Denilson - 0.5 - Very very poor game from him. Did he get booked?

Yes

 

[tactica442]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Right I give Denilson a 1.

 

[dutchMasta]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Almunia 6 (Could do nothing about goals)
Hoyte 4 (Really not the right players you want to be debuting with)
Djourou 5 (Decent until peno)
Silvestre 5 (Did decent)
Clichy 2 (Awful, passing off, at fault for 1st and crossing was crap)
Diaby 3 (Tried to dribble, but didn't work)
Denilson 1 (Get rid of him!!!)
Song 3 (Sloppy)
Nasri 6 (Could've done more, not ambitious)
Bendtner 4 (Sloppy)
RVP 6 (Tried)

Vela 4 (Couldn't get into the game)
Ramsey 6 (Good impact)

 

[CrazyInLoveWithArsenal]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Almunia 5-Made to look an idiot by Robinho, made a couple of decent saves.

Hoyte 4-Horrible for the lad that he had to make his PL debut in such circumstances
Silvestre 3-Okay
Djourou 3-Okay
Clichy 3-Expect so much more

Denilson 1-*****
Song 2-*****
Diaby 3-*****
Nasri 3-Okay

van Persie 3-He used to be a good player
Bentdner 1-*****

Ramsey 6-Best thing since sliced bread and Neil Mellor
Vela 5-Play him ahead of Bendtner ffs!

Wenger 10-The man is a genius!

 

[Invincible]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Almunia 3 - LOL
Djourou 5 - Ok
Silvestre 2 - Pisstake
Clichy 3 - Get your act together
Hoyte 3 - Feel sorry for him
Song 3 - Laughable
Denilson 0 - Thanks for turning up
Diaby 2 - Rubbish
Nasri 4 - Very average
van Persie 4 - Tried
Bendtner 1 - ****

Ramsey 6 - Our best player
Vela 5 - Should've started

 

[Anzac]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Almunia 6 (Could do nothing about goals)
Hoyte 4 (Really not the right players you want to be debuting with)
Djourou 5 (Decent until peno)
Silvestre 5 (Did decent)
Clichy 2 (Awful, passing off, at fault for 1st and crossing was crap)
Diaby 3 (Tried to dribble, but didn't work)
Denilson 1 (Get rid of him!!!)
Song 3 (Sloppy)
Nasri 6 (Could've done more, not ambitious)
Bendtner 4 (Sloppy)
RVP 6 (Tried)

Vela 4 (Couldn't get into the game)
Ramsey 6 (Good impact)

close enough for me - but you left out AW - gets a minus score for me based upon:
*conservative midfield selection;
*wrong forward selection;
*failure to change formation or tactics;
*failure to use ALL subs;
*continued use of players out of position;
*persistance with the dual MC ideology;
*for persisting with more of the same.
:roll:

 

[dutchMasta]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

close enough for me - but you left out AW - gets a minus score for me based upon:
*conservative midfield selection;
*wrong forward selection;
*failure to change formation or tactics;
*failure to use ALL subs;
*continued use of players out of position;
*persistance with the dual MC ideology;
*for persisting with more of the same.
:roll:

I don't rate Wenger (get it??...*sigh*). Not only those, we've got players hating each other, failing to spot and substitute the worst player (Denilson), failing to admit his failures, his deluded view that City didn't create many chances, and that we would've won had we not conceded those goals, etc. etc. We are officially entering potential crisis mode, where it looks like we might not even get 4th spot.

 

[GoonerGurjit]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

What a joke of signing Silvestre was.

 

[arsenalfc0719]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Almunia 3
Hoyte 3
Djourou 4
Silvest 3
Clichy 3
Diaby 2
Denilson 1
Song 3
Nasri 4
Bendtner 3
RVP 4

 

[Dennis10]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

What a joke of signing Silvestre was.

Iactually thought he were decent in large parts of the game, but the reason he proed useless in the end is the thing everybody was complaining about when he was back in Manchester. He does stupid mistakes once and a while. He must share the blame with Clichy for the first goal in my opinion.

Felt sorry for Denilson today. He looked close to a nervous breakdown towards the end. Talented fellow, but in the wrong place at a very wrong time these days. Diaby were horrid. One of the worst performances I've seen from an Arsenal player since David Hillier.

 

[HollandGooner]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Almunia 3
Hoyte 3
Djourou 4
Silvestre 3 Not the solution, Toure back please. with Djourou at the back
Clichy 3
Diaby 2 Inconsistent mixes with great peformances.
Denilson 0 how awfull can you be and play for Arsenal. its time that Denilson needs to be dropped, he isnt a first starter, maby i am a little bit harsh with my rating on him, but watching him for 90 minutes, cmone, he can do better then that.
Song 1 To much miss-passes.
Nasri 4
Bendtner 2 (Adebayor back please..) otherwise Vela upfront.
RVP 5

Vela where his teammates doenst seeing him?
Ramsey, should start our next game,

 

[Lukazan]

Re: Man City vs Arsenal Match Ratings

Almunia 5
Hoyte 5
Djourou 6
Silvestre 4
Clichy 3
Diaby 3
Denilson 1
Song 3
Nasri 5
Bendtner 2
RVP 3