Herbas
Well-Known Member
This season we lead the league for a long time and finally ended our trophy drought, but still no thread to evaluate all our players? Let's fix this.
Goalkeepers
Szczesny - 8 (a very solid season)
Fabianski - 9 (can't ask more from a backup keeper)
Defenders
Sagna - 7 (8 or even 8.5 for the first half of the season, but the second half was kinda poor)
Mertesacker - 9 (great season)
Vermaelen - 4 (very dissapointed in him, didn't challenge for the starting spot at all, was unreliable when called upon)
Koscielny - 9 (monster)
Monreal - 6 (subpar performances overall)
Jenkinson - 6 (I don't know actually, too few games to rate him)
Gibbs - 7 (nothing special)
Midfielders
Rosicky - 7.5 (difficult to rate, didn't have explosive performances like in the previous two seasons, but did his job well)
Arteta - 6.5 (not a starting material anymore for me)
Wilshere - 6.5 (subpar season)
Özil - 7.5 (acceptable first season, want a lot more in the next season)
Ramsey - 10 (exceeded even the wildest expectations)
Cazorla - 7 or 7.5 (huge drop from the previous season)
Flamini - 6.5 (did his job alright, but too limited)
Kallstrom - 7 (was alright as a 3645445th choice for a midfielder spot)
Forwards
Podolski - 7 (very poor in the first half, only the last couple of weeks saved him from 6 or even 5 rating)
Giroud - 7.5 (solid season, but the team needed more)
Walcott - 8 (promising, but missing)
Chamberlain - 8 (more end product and generally more impact to games)
Sanogo - 6.5 or 7 (alright, showed some promises, but did little on his own)
Gnabry - 7.5 or 8 (showed a lot more than I expected and he never looked out of place on the pitch)
Goalkeepers
Szczesny - 8 (a very solid season)
Fabianski - 9 (can't ask more from a backup keeper)
Defenders
Sagna - 7 (8 or even 8.5 for the first half of the season, but the second half was kinda poor)
Mertesacker - 9 (great season)
Vermaelen - 4 (very dissapointed in him, didn't challenge for the starting spot at all, was unreliable when called upon)
Koscielny - 9 (monster)
Monreal - 6 (subpar performances overall)
Jenkinson - 6 (I don't know actually, too few games to rate him)
Gibbs - 7 (nothing special)
Midfielders
Rosicky - 7.5 (difficult to rate, didn't have explosive performances like in the previous two seasons, but did his job well)
Arteta - 6.5 (not a starting material anymore for me)
Wilshere - 6.5 (subpar season)
Özil - 7.5 (acceptable first season, want a lot more in the next season)
Ramsey - 10 (exceeded even the wildest expectations)
Cazorla - 7 or 7.5 (huge drop from the previous season)
Flamini - 6.5 (did his job alright, but too limited)
Kallstrom - 7 (was alright as a 3645445th choice for a midfielder spot)
Forwards
Podolski - 7 (very poor in the first half, only the last couple of weeks saved him from 6 or even 5 rating)
Giroud - 7.5 (solid season, but the team needed more)
Walcott - 8 (promising, but missing)
Chamberlain - 8 (more end product and generally more impact to games)
Sanogo - 6.5 or 7 (alright, showed some promises, but did little on his own)
Gnabry - 7.5 or 8 (showed a lot more than I expected and he never looked out of place on the pitch)